The Simple Secret to Building a Discipleship Pathway That Actually Transforms Lives
Addressing the Challenge of Discipleship in 2025
If you’re like many pastors of small-to-midsized churches I’ve worked with, you’re eager to see your congregation grow in numbers and depth. You want to make disciples who love like Jesus and live lives marked by sacrificial love, generosity, humility, and courage. But when designing a clear discipleship pathway, you may feel stuck.
You’re not alone.
I’ve sat with pastors in your exact position—leaders overwhelmed by programs that don’t quite fit together and uncertain about what spiritual maturity even looks like in their context. They often feel pressure to produce results, but without a roadmap, they’re spinning their wheels. That’s where clarity changes everything. A clear discipleship pathway can help you align your church’s ministries and inspire lasting transformation.
Let’s explore how to start developing a pathway that guides people into the life Jesus calls them to live.
Discipleship Without Direction
Imagine a farmer planting seeds but never deciding what to grow. Some rows might yield tomatoes, others weeds, and others...well, nothing at all. Without a clear goal, the harvest will be random at best and disastrous at worst.
That’s where many churches find themselves with discipleship. We’re busy planting seeds, but we’re not clear on the crop. We want people to “grow spiritually,” but we haven’t defined what spiritual maturity looks like or how to cultivate it.
Here’s what I hear most often:
“We have lots of programs, but I’m not sure how they fit together.”
“I want to make disciples, but I don’t know what that means for us.”
“Our church feels stuck, and I’m not sure why.”
The villain here is confusion. Ministries often operate in silos, disconnected from a larger vision, leaving both leaders and members frustrated. The cost of this ambiguity is significant: people remain spiritually stagnant, church culture becomes reactive, and discipleship feels more like a buzzword than a reality.
If this resonates with you, I have some great news for you.
Start With the End in Mind
Discipleship begins with a clear picture of what you’re trying to grow. Start by asking yourself this question:
What does spiritual maturity look like in my church?
For many pastors, this is harder to answer than it seems. But if we don’t know where we’re headed, how can we guide others?
Here’s a practical exercise:
Write down a list of 12-15 spiritually mature individuals in your church.
Ask them this question: How would you describe spiritual maturity?
Compare their answers and look for common themes.
You might hear phrases like:
“Someone who loves others sacrificially, even their enemies.”
“A person who shows humility, generosity, and joy.”
“Someone deeply rooted in their faith but able to engage the world with grace.”
These responses will give you the raw material to craft a definition of maturity that fits your church.
The Importance of Alignment
Once you’ve defined maturity, the next step is evaluating your current ministries. Here’s the hard truth: not every program is helping your people grow into the kind of disciples Jesus calls them to be.
Take inventory of your church’s ministries and programs. For each, ask these questions:
Does this align with our definition of discipleship?
Does it help people move toward spiritual maturity?
Are there gaps or overlaps in what we’re offering?
This evaluation may reveal a few surprises. Perhaps a beloved ministry isn’t aligned with your vision, or you find that some areas (like Bible knowledge) are overemphasized while others (like relational connection) are neglected.
The goal is not to criticize but to clarify. Alignment allows you to invest your resources—time, energy, and people—into what truly matters.
Designing Your Discipleship Pathway
With a clear definition of spiritual maturity and an understanding of your church’s strengths and gaps, you can begin designing a discipleship pathway. This pathway should guide people through stages of growth, equipping them with the relationships, knowledge, and habits needed to mature.
A strong pathway includes:
Relationships: Who are people walking with on their journey? Are they part of an intentional, authentic community?
Story: Are they learning to locate their life in the grand narrative of Scripture and God’s mission?
Habits: Are they developing rhythms of prayer, study, generosity, and service that shape their character?
A healthy pathway is not a one-size-fits-all formula. It’s a custom roadmap tailored to your church’s unique DNA, with clear steps for people to follow.
Pro Tip: Simplify. Many pathways fail because they are too complicated or detailed. Focus on key stages and make it easy for people to understand where they are and where they’re going next.
Why This Matters
Why does clarity matter so much in discipleship? Because without it, we risk growing something other than what Jesus intends.
A church without a clear pathway often:
Produces burnout: Leaders exhaust themselves trying to do everything.
Cultivates confusion: Members are unsure how to grow or what’s expected of them.
Fails to reflect Jesus: People’s spiritual growth is inconsistent, leaving them less equipped to love sacrificially.
On the other hand, churches with clear pathways experience transformation:
Leaders are focused and energized.
Members see steady, measurable growth in their faith and relationships.
The church becomes a reflection of God’s kingdom—a community of love, joy, and peace.
When discipleship is clear, your church becomes a community where people want to stay, grow, and serve.
Do The Next Right Thing
Pastor, you don’t need to have everything figured out today. But you can take the first step.
Here’s your action plan:
Take 30 minutes to list 12-15 spiritually mature individuals in your church.
Ask them to describe spiritual maturity in their own words.
Begin crafting a “sticky” phrase or statement that clarifies spiritual maturity for your church.
With that foundation in place, you’ll be ready to align your ministries and design a pathway that transforms lives.
Developing a discipleship pathway isn’t easy work, but it’s worth it. Your church can become a community where spiritual maturity is not the exception but the norm—where people love like Jesus, serve sacrificially and shine as a light in the world.
So take a deep breath. You don’t have to do this alone, and you don’t have to get it perfect. Start where you are, with what you have, and trust that God will guide the way.
(P.S. If you’d like help developing your discipleship pathway, let’s talk. I’d love to support you in this journey.)
Transformational Leadership is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.